Sports cards are an exciting way to recognize the best athletes from your favorite league or team. Many people collect trading cards as a hobby, and you could be the next addition to their collection.
Whether you’re a longtime collector or want to flip cards, now is a great time to sell some of your portfolio. However, finding the right place to sell your cards can seem difficult.
There are several places to sell your sports cards online or locally for money, and we’ve found the best options to help you maximize your profits.
The Best Places to Sell Your Sports Cards
When it comes to selling your sports cards, you have a lot of options. Try getting quotes from several sources to find the best price for the cards you want to sell.
Here are some of the best places to sell your sports cards in alphabetical order.
- Beckett
Many sports card collectors are familiar with Beckett pricing guides and listings. The online site also allows you to trade cards with registered members.
Unfortunately, individual collectors cannot sell their cards for cash.
However, if you have an extensive collection and can verify your card grades, you can call the service and become a registered dealer in the Beckett marketplace.
It’s $6.99 per month or $64.99 per year after a 30-day free trial.
Membership benefits include.
Real-time price guide
Track card sale prices
Electronic trading platform
Organize multiple collections
Creating wish lists
If you still collect credit cards, you can also join a loyalty program. You will earn points that can be redeemed for discounts on future orders.
- WBC Forum
The Wellspring Forum lets you talk to other collectors about the latest sports news and your collection.
These sports and hobby threads exist for.
Baseball
Basketball
Coins
Comic Books
Fantasy Sports
Soccer
games
Soccer
Unfortunately, these threads do not allow you to sell or trade sports cards.
Instead, you’ll need to visit the online Blowout store to see if you have cards on the “wanted” list. In most cases, you must sell unopened boxes from the last five years.
You can also sell these collectibles through the online store.
Autographed cards
Game Habit Collectibles
Panini Reward Points
Pokémon boxes
Your payment options include PayPal, checks, and store credit.
- Card Up
Local card shows are a fun way to connect with dealers and collectors. Many buyers can check out your collection, which gives you many opportunities to sell.
You can also sell a wider variety of cards as you are not limited to the demand list of the online marketplace.
Selling locally can even help you avoid platform fees and shipping costs that online stores may charge. However, you may need to purchase an admission ticket and drive to the venue.
You can find upcoming fights by searching online for “card shows near me” or asking your local sports card store.
- CNC
Check Out My Collection (COMC) lets you sell sports cards, trading cards and collectibles.
This platform is similar to an online consignment store because you mail your items and then COMC advertises and ships them for purchase to buyers.
You can sell individual cards. Currently, this site does not support unopened packs or complete sets.
Processing fees range from $0.50 to $2.00 per card. Splurging on the more expensive fees will shorten your processing time from a maximum of 16 weeks to as soon as two weeks.
Cards expected to sell for $50 or more can also be sold on eBay. Less expensive credit cards are sold on the COMC online store, but with lower processing fees.
Some of the services you can get include.
Scanning the front and back of each card
Condition evaluation
Advertising
Shipping to the buyer
Customer service support
Your payment options include store credit, PayPal, and checks.
- Dave & Adam’s
dave&adams home page
You can find modern and vintage cards and sets for sale at Dave & Adam ‘s. Non-sports gaming equipment is also popular.
Modern, individual cards may need to be worth at least $50 or have a professional grade (i.e. PSA, BGS or SGC).
Graded or original vintage cards from 1970 or earlier are also welcome.
Sealed packs and complete sets are even available for sale. The Buy List shows what the service is currently buying and your selling price.
You ship your collection via UPS or FedEx and receive payment within 48 hours of the package’s arrival. As a bonus, you will receive a $25 gift certificate when you sell at least $500.
When you pay for shipping, any declined cards can be returned for free.
Your payment method is PayPal, check or store credit.
- eBay
If you are willing to list your products and find buyers, you can sell your sports cards on eBay. The auction style and fixed price listings give you the flexibility to make top dollar.
Selling your own collection minimizes your seller’s fees because you’re not paying someone to list your products for you.
However, potential buyers may be hesitant to buy from an individual seller rather than a reputable dealer because they may want to avoid scams. Professionally grading cards and high-resolution photos will help.
While you can make more money on eBay, you will incur fees.
These fees include.
Seller’s fees:12.35% of the final sale value
Shipping costs:Varies (you can ask the buyer to pay this fee)
You do not currently pay insertion fees to list your products. If something doesn’t sell, you won’t incur any fees.
- Facebook Groups
Facebook lets you reach out to local and distant buyers through its Marketplace feature. Listing your items and selling them locally is free.
However, items that need to be shipped incur a selling fee. You pay a 5% fee for each shipment ($0.40 for sales of $8 or less). This fee is lower than other online selling apps.
Joining a local buying and selling group is another way to make money on Facebook. You can also find groups online that specialize in sports cards.
While you can avoid platform fees and reduced expenses for the sports card dealers you meet, Facebook offers less seller protection.
Be sure to screen potential buyers to avoid payment scams that are common in any DIY marketplace. Thankfully, Facebook has a database of scammers that lists some of the profiles you should avoid.
8 Kruk Cards
Kruk Cards has a local store in Michigan, but you might consider paying to ship your valuable cards.
If you have a large collection, the company may also arrange to pick up your items.
This online site has an active shopping list of the most desired items for various sports. You can make a list of your “star” cards and autographs so you can get an estimate and discuss shipping and payment options.
If you have at least 5,000 regular cards, you can sell them for a few dollars.
You can also sell Pokemon, Magic and Yu-Gi-Oh! cards.
- local hobby and sports card stores
One of the easiest ways to profit from your collection is to visit your local card store. You may prefer this option if you have a relationship with the store owner and trust their operation.
Staying local means that you can also make money quickly, as you won’t waste time in transit or waiting for vendors to process your collection.
Because of the size of your collection, some online stores may take two weeks or more to evaluate your collection. By selling to a local store, you may be able to get same-day quotes and easily take home unwanted cards.
While local sports card stores are convenient, your buyback offer may be lower than elsewhere. Unfortunately, these stores aren’t as common as more collectors are shopping online.
- OfferUp
OfferUp is a popular buy and sell app that allows you to sell locally or nationally. However, it may not have as many users as Facebook.
Once you download the app, you can use your phone to upload a photo of your card, write a short description, and set your selling price.
You can communicate with potential buyers in the app to negotiate the sale. Local parties are free, but you pay a 12.9% service fee ($1.99 minimum) when you ship your items.
Buyers pay for shipping, which helps reduce your seller fees.
Our OfferUp seller reviews can help you learn how to effectively sell your unwanted items.
- Otia.
Otia Sports primarily buys vintage sports cards from 1975 or earlier. You can also sell modern cards and sets.
The platform says that they will buy your entire collection instead of sending rejected cards back.
Before mailing the cards, you can send a message with a list of your collection and a photo of the vintage card. You will receive a tentative buyback offer valid for 30 days.
If you accept the job, you can mail your credit card and receive payment by cash, check or PayPal.
After successfully selling your cards and memorabilia to Otia, you can recommend the service to friends. If they use Otia, you get a 10% commission on the purchase price.
- PSA Card Forum
There are several sports card grading services worth selling valuable trading cards. Professional Sports Authentication (PSA) is one such service that you can sell or trade on their online forum.
First, you create a thread and upload a photo of the item you wish to sell. The forum accepts modern and vintage cards from any sport.
You then negotiate payment and shipping details directly with the buyer.
- SlabStox
SlabStox is a free online trading platform that helps you keep track of popular cards and the current prices of your collection.
You can also sell cards to other community members. However, this site is relatively young and still has a small user base, so it may take longer for your cards to sell.
- StockX
StockX is an online marketplace for collectibles that tracks real-time prices. You can set your asking price and wait for buyers to accept it.
The site’s selling fees include.
Transaction fees (up to 10%)
Payment processing fee (3%)
You can minimize transaction fees by having at least three sales and $500 in sales.
Most products are complete collections, but you can also sell single cards.
In addition to trading cards, you can also sell.
Collectibles
Game Cards
Watches
Sneakers
Streetwear
Read our StockX review to learn more about this platform.
- TonyeTrade
TonyeTrade specializes in selling vintage baseball cards, which are often the most valuable sports cards.
You can also sell these items:.
Comics
Non-baseball sports cards
Sports Memorabilia
Most items are vintage from the 1970s or earlier. However, the most valuable modern trading cards can also be profitable.
You can start the selling process by sharing your inventory and condition by contacting the service. For your most valuable items, you may be able to get an instant purchase offer.
In other cases, TonyeTrade can consign your items and help you find buyers. However, your selling fees may vary depending on the method of sale.
